Sunday, March 05, 2006

Destination ImagiNation results

What an experience! It was my first year coaching a D.I. (Destination ImagiNation) team. I had four third-grade boys. (Yes, I thought many times, "kill me now!") We took on the improvisational challenge, with absolutely no presentation, acting or improv skills.

My son was one of the four boys. It was very frustrating for the boys, being the youngest in their level of competition, and with this being the first year they were actually going to get a score. They were very excited about the prospect of advancing to the state tournament. Honestly, I knew they wouldn't make it, but I really didn't want to rain on their parade. I kept a very open, "we'll see what happens," attitude.

Half-way through the process of preparing for competition, we fell apart. The boys were being boys, and I asked their teachers for help. Once the parents had been looped in to a very crazy game of "operator," everyone was hurt, angry, and we all wanted to throw in the towel. Except for four determined boys. Up to this point, D.I. was "fun," and, frankly, a chance to socialize outside of school. I struggled greatly with balancing letting them learn their own lessons, and preparing them for the *huge* challenge ahead. The last thing I wanted to do was to let them continue on their path of ... well, socializing... get to competition and be surprised that they were actually supposed to do research and practice some skills. As a coach, I couldn't sit back and let them do that.

Apparently, not sitting back -- pushing these boys -- was the right decision. I'd like to say that we took this DIsaster to a top-ranking team, but let's still be realistic. They were competing against fifth- and sixth-graders with many more years of experience than these boys. However, this team of four third-grade boys pushed themselves to pay attention during evening meetings. (Can anything be worse on a child?) They didn't fully "get it," just what they were supposed to accomplish, during these meetings, but they did try. Every week. The did not understand what they were supposed to be practicing and researching between meetings. But, they showed up the morning of competition, ready for whatever they were to face.

Okay, now for the results. The boys drew a very difficult combination of elements, one they knew from practice that was just going to be hard. They pulled together a skit and performed it. That right there satisfied my definition of accomplishment. For them, they scored 139 out of 300. It doesn't sound stellar, but their scores reflected points in every category. In other words, they did *everything* they were supposed to do. Maybe they didn't do it with the level of sophistication that was called for by the challenge's definition, but they did it.

These boys didn't let anything scare them. Even now, they have a much bigger sense of what they could have done, but they have a sense of pride because they participated and didn't give up.

I went into this competition day, fully committed to never looking back at D.I. once that performance was complete. I hated the entire process. I dreaded every meeting. But, now that we're done, I found myself staying behind to wait for the scores. Everyone from our team left, except my family. And when we got the scores and one element came back with a zero score, I challenged. I knew these boys knew that they had met this element, and I knew what I had to do. I challenged, and the judges agreed.

They gave us the points for including the element, and 0.83 points out of 25 for the way they included it. Yes, it's a pathetic score. But, now I can go back to them with that score sheet. And they'll listen. They'll have to, if they want to improve for their performance next year.

4 comments:

Joe said...

Sounds like you did a great job, as the boys were excited about the event and they gave it their all and more importantly there was progression.

Some of my favorite teams to coach were the ones that had no hope in hell, but work hard and even through they still lost, enjoyed getting better.

some good parenting there.

xyb said...

Wow! Thank you!

(I'm assuming this is joe-joe-dancer.)

I just got the rankings, and we were dead *last* for our challenge. I don't think I'll share that tidbit with the boys, though.

I really liked doing this, but I think I'll steer this team to something more suited to them, like Lego FIRST, which has a junior league for this age group.

Joe said...

it is gawain and the lego first sounds like a great idea.

xyb said...

Oh, I just ran across this, which is local for us: http://rocksandrobots.com/

It's a summer camp that focuses on geology-type topics, surival and orienteering, as well as robotics. They use the Lego Mindstorm kits for the younger kids. The older ones get to hack the humanoid robots!

It's *way* expensive, though. I think the plan is to go through one round of FIRST, then the camp. We'll see!